Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
bigfan89

PENNY AND SHELDON MAYBE?

Penny & Sheldon a Couple   235 votes

  1. 1. Penny & Sheldon a Couple

    • YES
      41
    • NO
      194

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

1,340 posts in this topic

Posted

Jim is a sweetheart. The only reason I have No Physical Attraction to him is I would not be his type... Sheldon on the other hand: Yes, he is attractive!

 

Having a crush on Mayim: YES, she does have Sex Appeal!

 

Jim and Sheldon both do IMHO. Mayim may have sex appeal, but that's not relevant. The character she plays doesn't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

We were speaking of Mayim not Amy. They are completely different people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Sheldon talking about Penny's sex life on a FWF taping episode that he would post on YouTube for anyone to see, not cool at all Sheldon. Sheldon wanting to take electronic games to Penny's play because he didn't want to watch her performance, pretty rude and selfish Sheldon. Of course Leonard steps in and sticks up for his girlfriend Penny by taking those things away from Sheldon like the loving boyfriend he is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I just discovered a site called shennyhomes. But is for a realtor. Good way of getting more hits. Shenny is apparently a real name. Who knew.

Spaced_up likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I just discovered a site called shennyhomes. But is for a realtor. Good way of getting more hits. Shenny is apparently a real name. Who knew.

 

Fancy that! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

10 reasons why Shenny would be the worse thing that could happen on the show:

 

1) It would destroy the Shamy -> Amy would be devistated and very very disappointed and angry all together

2)It would destroy the Shelnard friendship -> Leonard would feel betrayed by Sheldon

3) It would destroy the Penny/Leonard relationship -> Leonard would be devistated

4) Amy would end her friendship with Penny

5) Bernadette wouldn`t know who to friends with anymore (and in that case I mean continuing the friendship with someone)

6) Howard would feel the same like Bernadette

7) Raj would be a little confused

8 ) the Sheldon/Leonard/Howard/Raj friendship would be destroyed

9) the girls friendship would be destroyed and they wouldn`t talk to each other anymore

10) the whole concept would be destroyed

 

Anyway: Those would be the concequences for one realtionship for which they would have to destroy two and a lot of friendships. And thats really not worth it. Not for me and not for a lot other people.

 

And very important: If the people who ship Penny and Sheldon wanna ship them: Keep doing that and interpret  the scenes how ever you want even if its beside the point a lot of times. I just wanna clear up that I never wanna attack any Penny/Sheldon shipper with that thats not my intension.

 

Thats all I have to say about that and there´s nothing more to say.

I`m done with it.

Edited by BlackWhiteRose
mjc45 and legacy99 like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Thats all I have to say about that and there´s nothing more to say.

 

That's fine, but one wonders why you had to resurrect a two-year-old dead thread in order to say it.

ATOB likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Spookily enough I was just lamenting the exodus of the Shennies from this site on another thread.

Nice bit of forum archeology. Digging down, scraping away to 2011 when these now almost mythical figures walked among us.

Yes, yes, they were real; yes, yes they were here, these Arthurian-like freethinking figures of folklaw, authentic in their living, breathing, different opinioned beings.

hazelra7 likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I love their interactions on-screen but not as a couple. I think they are the best pair on tbbt when it comes to making jokes happen IYKWIM. Sadly, recently when I discovered some shennies bashing Amy-then Mayim-and now, Jim, I started to get internal defensive thoughts. Now, whenever I see cute sheldon and penny interactions I'm like "what are those shennies gonna say now?" Because of them, I can't appreciate shenny interactions than I did before. So sad that this is how my brain works.

EvilStewie likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

First off Jim is gay in real life and married second of all you post is all over the place and contradicts itself. One minute you want them together the next you don't. Please make your mind up. Thirdly I don't think we are watching the same show.

Sent from my SM-G928F using Tapatalk

BlackWhiteRose and mjc45 like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

This thread give me gas.  It wounds me and my soul.  But to each their own, ( I say with grinding teeth and stiff drink as I compliment my feigned tolerance)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

On 1/12/2016 at 7:57 AM, EternalOptimist said:

Penny and Sheldon have great acting chemistry and if Jim and Kaley end up together in real life, even better. However, I hate when plotlines tease Shenny or depict Sheldon and Penny as perfect while Amy and Leonard are depicted as manipulative and evil for comic relief. The truth is if Shenny was the ultimate endgame it should have happened already, or Sheldon should have never been given a love interest. Amy should have been introduced as another Leslie Winkle. Leonard could have even dated Amy to annoy Sheldon even further. Personally, I preferred when Leonard was in relationships with someone other than Penny (Priya, Stephanie, even Alex would have been interesting to see). He was much more confident and interesting.

However, anyone including Amy, Bernadette, Priya, Alex, Stephanie, etc. that pose a challenge to Penny are quickly turned into being mean or possessive or a cheater to elevate Penny. Leonard has always pined for Penny. Even when he was dating Priya, he was upset when he thought Raj and Penny slept together. However, even though Penny doesn't seem to love Leonard, she does not like the idea of Leonard dating anyone else. That is not fair. You should not hold your partner hostage, simply because someone is threatening to interfere, if you do not truly love them.

During Season 4 and 5, Sheldon genuinely respected Amy. He was jealous of Stuart and Leonard. However, during Season 6, 7, and 8, when there were no romantic threats, more "Shenny" teases and more Shamy conflict ensued. Sheldon lied to Kripke about having sex with Amy to save his reputation, but with no respect for Amy. Sheldon could have broken up at anytime if he felt it was too much pressure and the whole Shenny arc could have been established. Sheldon initiated the first breakup. They could have remained broken up. Sheldon could have broken up during the table episode despite being fed lines, because he clearly stopped repeating when Amy mentioned moving in. Sheldon mentioned breaking up in 8.1 after Amy told him it was ok he was not perfect. Sheldon is often depicted that his words are not deliberately hurtful. However, why is Sheldon allowed to be mean, jealous, or upset about Amy when he threatened multiple attempts to breakup, is willing to throw Amy under the bus, and even at one point wished she was dead?

Also, Sheldon asked Penny not to hurt his friend when he found out Penny was contemplating breaking up with Leonard. Yet, Penny did not reciprocate the favor when Penny learned that Amy was debating her relationship with Sheldon. Everyone teases Amy about not getting sex, but the moment Sheldon says he is ready, everyone wonders if it is the right time for him. I wish Amy would have waited for marriage, but again Leonard and Amy just seem to be disposable. Even Stuart was likable when he dated Penny (Batman discussion with Sheldon), but he was also turned into a creepy disposable character too.

This is supposed to be a comedy.  I wish they would have killed off Amy and Leonard's characters rather than tarnish it.  Penny and Sheldon could have gotten together after 10 years of platonic friendship without ever even dating Leonard, Stuart, or Amy. To create all this angst and drama, and oscillation to breakup two long term couples, only to elevate one golden couple at the end and at the expense of other characters is unnecessary.

Lol your talking like Sheldon and Penny ever had romantic undertone or were ever going to date EWWW. Penny would throw up at the idea. Its a maternal relationship for heck sakes, I mean how after all these years ie that not getting through. The golden couple as always been Leonard and Penny. Leonard and Penny were endgame in the pilot when they meet. I have no idea where your getting these presumptions from. That some how all this angst is all about elevating Sheldon and Penny lol. Sorry you clearly are not watching the show I am watching. For the record Jim is gay. So they won't be gettng together. Kaley dated Johnny in real life.  Penny doesen't love Leonard? Yeah thats why she married the guy LOL. For the love of everything, buld a brdige. Their was never any Sheldon and Penny. This is not the story. The story is Hot girl next doors falls for nerd (Leonard). I mean let it go lord. TBH its shallow as the only reason anyone ever shipped Sheldon and Penny, is because Jim and Kaley are good looking. That is it. Johnny played sheldon, it woilden't even exist. 

Edited by 3ku11

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

13 minutes ago, Einstein Von Brainstorm said:

*dies laughing* :rofl: 

Stealing that one :wink: 

Glad you like it, steal away!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I will never understand why people always try to compare Jim's RL sexual orientation to that of Sheldon on the show.   Mayim is a vegetarian in RL, but she wanted a bite of Sheldon's burger on the show.    What's the point?   There is a difference between the actor, and the character the actor is portraying.  

Sheldon will never be with Penny.   Not only are they not compatible, but she's married to Leonard now.

I ship them as friends, but never as a couple.

April, mjc45, EvilStewie and 1 other like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

9 minutes ago, jenafan said:

I will never understand why people always try to compare Jim's RL sexual orientation to that of Sheldon on the show.   Mayim is a vegetarian in RL, but she wanted a bite of Sheldon's burger on the show.    What's the point?   There is a difference between the actor, and the character the actor is portraying.  

Sheldon will never be with Penny.   Not only are they not compatible, but she's married to Leonard now.

I ship them as friends, but never as a couple.

I've also heard that he might not actually be a scientist in real life!

... I hope that it's just a horrible rumour though cus I don't think I could enjoy the show anymore if I found out that Jim Parsons didn't actually know what a Carbon nanotube was! 

mjc45, jenafan, EvilStewie and 2 others like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

9 hours ago, jenafan said:

I will never understand why people always try to compare Jim's RL sexual orientation to that of Sheldon on the show.   Mayim is a vegetarian in RL, but she wanted a bite of Sheldon's burger on the show.    What's the point?   There is a difference between the actor, and the character the actor is portraying.  

Sheldon will never be with Penny.   Not only are they not compatible, but she's married to Leonard now.

I ship them as friends, but never as a couple.

They have chemistry on screen, both are good looking people. I'm not surprised about it, but it still makes me gag

Edited by EvilStewie
hazelra7 likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

On 1/15/2016 at 9:51 PM, jenafan said:

but she wanted a bite of Sheldon's burger on the show.

Is that a Euphemism? :icon_biggrin: 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

On 3/9/2015 at 8:34 AM, ATOB said:

Spookily enough I was just lamenting the exodus of the Shennies from this site on another thread.

 

Nice bit of forum archeology. Digging down, scraping away to 2011 when these now almost mythical figures walked among us.

 

Yes, yes, they were real; yes, yes they were here, these Arthurian-like freethinking figures of folklaw, authentic in their living, breathing, different opinioned beings.

If the Shenny's walked among us, can you imagine the fights?  Given how the Lenny's and Shamys go at it, I couldn't imagine a forum with Shenny's too. I have a hard enough time reading the FF.net description of the stories, let alone some of the posts.   Dogs and Cats living together, mass hysteria!  

 

Shipping a couple is a personal thing, and tears at people's inner need to see themselves as one of the couples in the Ship.  We identify with one of the characters and latch on to the idea.  When they are placed with another... less than worthy... cough cough... (Penny).... then we get our dander up.  I was not on the forums when Shenny's were around.  I bet the debates were lively and also much hurt feelings.  I dont have the emotional capital to handle that kind of debate. I am still taking xanax over the Shenny kiss in the premier.  However, I can see how it made for a more well rounded forum.

I do take issue with the idea that they can be classified as "free-thinkers"  Shenny's ship their couple as hard as anyone, and just because their couple isnt canon, doesnt mean they get the free thinkers label.  I reserve that for Howaraj lovers  among us.  Now that is some out the box thinking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

6 hours ago, hazelra7 said:

If the Shenny's walked among us, can you imagine the fights?  Given how the Lenny's and Shamys go at it, I couldn't imagine a forum with Shenny's too. I have a hard enough time reading the FF.net description of the stories, let alone some of the posts.   Dogs and Cats living together, mass hysteria!  

 

 

Yeah! I remember watching the episode when Leonard dreams Sheldon and Penny kissed.. I cringed, not cause they kissed, but cause I KNEW it was gonna cause bedlam on all TBBT related sites I got to, FF.net, here.. facebook

Kathy2611 and Arduina like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

6 hours ago, hazelra7 said:

Shipping a couple is a personal thing

I totally agree.

Aside from the fact they are cute and lovable, I can't really explain why I ship Shamy, over the other couples.

Maybe it's something to do with their innocence (although that's no longer the case), or their nerdy/dorky-ness.

Whatever it is, I ship the Shamy hard, and am not ashamed to admit it.

Edited by Stephen Hawking

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

31 minutes ago, EvilStewie said:

Yeah! I remember watching the episode when Leonard dreams Sheldon and Penny kissed.. I cringed, not cause they kissed, but cause I KNEW it was gonna cause bedlam on all TBBT related sites I got to, FF.net, here.. facebook

I saw that taped... I have scars.  Deep emotional scars... 

mirs1, mjc45 and EvilStewie like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

3 minutes ago, hazelra7 said:

I saw that taped... I have scars.  Deep emotional scars... 

Oh Sweetie!! I'm so glad you're a writer and have an outlet to get that out, cause that is ..REALLY icky!

hazelra7 likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

2 hours ago, EvilStewie said:

Oh Sweetie!! I'm so glad you're a writer and have an outlet to get that out, cause that is ..REALLY icky!

Actually, wrote a chapter of Six Sheldon's that referred to it.  I had to, you see....to cleanse...

EvilStewie and Arduina like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0