[[Spoilers] Season 11 Discussion Thread]

I don't think it was a throw away line either and I think we could still see Penny having those(or one of them) babies by the end without having a pregnancy story. We could find out in the finale(like many have said) that she is pregnant or even the episode before the last and have the last be a fast forward to her having the baby(not likely but you never know).

When the writers wrote in Bernadette's first pregnancy I think they did it as a last minute thing but to me it worked. They had been married for almost 4 years which for a couple is a good amount of alone time together before children.(I was married almost 6 when I had my first) So if we go by that natural progression Leonard and Penny will be married 4 years in the finale(assuming season 12 is the last). I think that is a perfect amount of time to bring in those smart and beautiful babies.

And as many have said, the writers could change their minds if they get a 13th season. One can only hope.

Here is something this Shamy fan doesn't want....Amy pregnant before Penny(or together.....leave that for fanfiction) and a storyline around that. I am happy enough knowing they have the babies from the line in Young Sheldon. It works for me(maybe not others but definitely me).

 

 

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 11]

14 minutes ago, SpoonMouse said:

Another thing that I absolutely adored was seeing Penny being a total badass. She handled Amy's mom with more grace than she deserved, especially when she assumed that her daughter had been stood up. After all the years of ribbing and teasing, after all that time encouraging Amy to move on even when she knew that Sheldon had a ring for her, she stood up for Sheldon even when he wasn't there. She believed so much in the strength of their bond, that she was willing to fight everyone who disagreed with her. If it wasn't clear before, today's episode really proved to everyone how much she loves them both, and how she'd go to any lengths to make the day special for them.

She encouraged Sheldon to take Amy on a date and get to know her better, she gave him the courage to ask Amy to be his girlfriend, she helped him take the first step towards cementing his physical bond with Amy, she gave him advice when they moved in together, she helped him understand that a little compromise goes a long way in a relationship, and she's always been genuinely happy for their progress, no matter how big or how small. And now, it was fitting we got to see her play such a big part in their wedding.

Penny is truly the Shamy shipper we don't deserve. All hail the queen of Shamy shippers!

 

If I could like this 1000 times I would. Well said!

[[Spoilers] Season 11 Discussion Thread]

1 hour ago, Judith said:

That was a lovely tribute to Stephen Hawking! Btw they couldn't have included this in 12.1 because by then it would be too late for a tribute. It was already a bit late-ish since he died two months ago.

I think they could have included it in the first episode. We saw Bernadette opening gifts in 6.2 and that wasn't 4 months after they were married. I wish they would have showed it last night though. I actually forgot all about it until after my second watching of the show and I was like wait they didn't include the Stephen Hawking tribute.

The tribute was absolutely perfect though.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 11]

This was absolute perfection for me. The guest stars were not overused and had lines at just the right moment. I loved every minute of this episode.

I have not looked forward to a wedding on television as much as I waited for this one and they did not disappoint me in any way.

I was worried the vows would be overly cheesy but I cried like a baby when Amy said hers. And Sheldon being at a loss for words was just too much. He always has something to say and then couldn't even get out his thoughts.

And then YS with the tag made me scream out loud....children! He said children(plural not just 1) OMG....I love it.

 

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 11]

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 11]

42 minutes ago, Babar said:

OMG OMG OMG!!!!! I'm not crying I swear.

 

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

5 minutes ago, spidergirl said:

"Darling" by Beach Boys would be cool imo

And that's  a great idea! Thanks for that!

I've done one with that, I will definitely use it. I also have The Only Conclusion which is an obvious choice.

I love making the videos and I was going to wait until after a proposal to make my next one. Well we have it so I guess I will make it.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

My favorite scene of the season! I knew it. Thanks so much April for doing this for us.

I've been thinking I may make a video highlighting these scenes. So song requests anyone? I can use several to make the video.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

These two are definitely in my top 3. Loved Buridan's Donkey....no pressure from Amy whatsoever and he just casually walked into the apartment and that was that. No more talking no more deciding.

And who couldn't love the MRI gift as well as the annual birthday booty spectacular.

I have a feeling I know what number 1 is and I hope I am right. I guess I will find out tomorrow.

 

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

1 hour ago, April said:

Previously on our countdown: [#10] [#9] [#8] [#7]

Your Top 10 Favourite Season 10 Shamy Moments

#6

As promised this will be a whopper cause we got another tie! And not just a simple one between two moments - but three lovely scenes got the same score of 43 points!! :D

10x05 Shamy take their relationship to the next level

This is pretty self-explanatory. Easily one of the most wonderful Shamy hugs to date!

(11 people voted for this scene)

10x13 The big goodbye in 4A

There's so much to love about this: the "I miss you x+1" one-upmanship, the kiss, and who doesn't want to know how Godzilla showers now?? These two!

(11 people voted for this scene)

10x14 "I love you exactly the way you are." - "I feel the same way about you."

Because nobody can get enough of lovey-dovey supportive Shamy! <3

(10 people voted for this scene)

I hope that'll hold you over the weekend! I'll be back on Monday for #5!!

Now I know why I never got you mine....too many little moments like this to choose from. IT would have been impossible to pick just ten.

Love these three!

Thanks again April for putting so much effort into doing this.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

1 hour ago, April said:

Previously on our countdown: [#10] [#9] [#8]

Your Top 10 Favourite Season 10 Shamy Moments

#7

10x15 Amy's train fantasy

Our daily nugget of Shamy goodness for today is for the ladies and gents who like to see Sheldon douse himself with cold water. Amy's fantasies never disappoint in delivering the fanservice! ;D

(6 people voted for this scene giving it 37 points in total.)

Come back tomorrow for a big one on #6!

Oh I can just watch this gif over and over and over.....

 

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

51 minutes ago, April said:

Previously on our countdown: [#10]

Your Top 10 Favourite Season 10 Shamy Moments

#9

10x11 "I thought I'd let Harry Potter make things hotter!" - "Wowza!"

After all that intellectual flirting we'll get more physical this time around. They may claim Sheldon's attraction to Amy's body was all about her blood type and harvesting organs but that look on his face when she comes out in her Harry Potter get up ain't fooling anyone!

(9 people voted for this moment and it got 32 points in total.)

Check back tomorrow for #8!

This definitely would have made my top 10.

Can't wait for #8

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

23 hours ago, April said:

Alright, Shamies, let's do this!

Your Top 10 Favourite Season 10 Shamy Moments

#10

And right off the bat we're starting with a tie! Conveniently they're also a wonderful thematic match: S10 saw the big comeback of Shamy and their relationship of the mind - except now it's more like a hot love affair that literally makes them "randy" as Sheldon put it. Without further ado, these are the scene you voted for the #10 spot with 30 points each:

From episode 10x06 Sheldon surprises Amy with a brunch and a flirt over (un)surprising surprises ensues!

(5 people in total voted for this scene.)

And from 10x24 Amy and Sheldon get caught up in a grammar flirt!

(6 people in total voted for this scene.)

See ya tomorrow for #9!

I love this and I could kick myself for having a major brain fart and forgetting to send my top ten in.(I remembered Sunday...UGH!)

I have always loved their Skype calls. And now I absolutely love the flirting. So much stuff from this season I can't believe we got it down to just ten.

 

Thanks so much @April for doing this.....I can't wait to see #9 later today.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

29 minutes ago, April said:

Not that I don't appreciate everybody's likes on this post but I'd actually like some answers to these questions! The earlier we clear this up the earlier we can start!! :D

I think ten is more than enough....although I could easily find 15.

I think no more than two weeks  should be sufficient time if rewatches are necessary to make final decisions.

I like the idea of tallying up the results and doing a countdown is a great idea. You could put one up a day and surprise us.

Seriously if you need help I would be happy to help also.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

3 hours ago, April said:

A few weeks ago I offered to do a "Top 10 Shamy Moments of S10" - if you guys want me to I can organise the whole thing. Y/N??

Yes!!

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

3 minutes ago, Capt. Hilts said:

Does everyone here buy into the idea that it's totally up to the man to decide when to get married?  Do we all still really live in that world?

A proposal seems silly, to me, when Amy has made it abundantly clear for YEARS she'd like to get married.

I don't think it is totally up to the man but in this situation I would say it is. I think we all know the answer will be yes as you said she has made it abundantly clear she wants to get married. Sheldon had to be the one to say okay let's do this. Plus we know he has had the ring for two years and Amy's known for a year so she was waiting for him to say it's time.

It was like Mary said...."You have to take your time with Shelly."  Amy waited and the reward will be great.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

1 hour ago, snapepans said:

I think it will be fun if we create our own "Awards" about Shamy in Season 10.

Like: The Best Hug, The Best Kiss, The Funniest Moment, The Funniest Dialogue, The Most Heartfelt Scene, etc, etc.  And we can attach the related GIF pictures to them.

And, then, we can make a Wish List of Shamy in Season 11(and 12). 

PS: These are some of my small contributions for this thread to reach 500 pages. 

I think if we do that or a top ten list we can easily fill pages to get to 500 pages. Love this idea!

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

38 minutes ago, serena_1995 said:

Whether Ramona is in season 11 or not, do you think Sheldon should/will tell Amy about Ramona kissing him in the premiere of next season ? 

I think he will because

1) He is a terrible liar, he couldn't keep it from her.

2) Amy is going to want to know what brought on him coming all the way out from California to propose.

3) The writers won't do that again, right? Right?(Okay I know they like drama but they can't keep that secret again)

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

I don't want Amy leaving Princeton either. I like the idea of the gang stepping in and taking care of Ramona. Who knows what the writers have plaInned. She probably will be a one and done guest star. I'd be fine with that too.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

13 minutes ago, joyceraye said:

Bold : This is what I've been thinking. It makes sense to me. Ramona was an admirer of Sheldon's work and also had an infatuation with him. She's never forgotten him. Now she comes back all triumphant to lay her trophies at his feet. I'm waiting to see and hear her expressions before I decide whether I feel sorry for her, carrying a torch all these years, or not. If I feel sorry for her and she regrets her moves on Sheldon having accepted he's not available, I hope she takes up with Raj or Stuart and is good for him. (It's time we had somebody getting behind Stuart and turning him into a success.)   If not, I hope she gets Kripke.

Yes, I'd like to  see a quickie marriage in N J and then parties and receptions when they get home, including a nice do-over in Texas. Bernadette and Raj to organise.

I don't understand what Penny is telling Sheldon about his being a limited edition toy, mint in box, and what it has to do with Ramona's designs.

 

I agree if her actions are regretted I will forgive her. If not I hope Amy comes down hard.

I think Penny means that it's like the toy that everyone wants but there are only a few so it is very coveted. Sheldon's answer is perfect.....I'm not that mint in box any more, Amy has played with me so I am not as good. Not in those words but I think that is the meaning behind it.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

2 hours ago, spidergirl said:

I have had an earlier chat with @mirs1 about Ramona in s2 and I thought it was a funny plot at first time I watched Cooper theorem episode because we had not seen Sheldon interacting with women in a way so close as we saw in that episode. And of course because Amy did not exist in his life yet.

Last week I have rewatched it again and I thought it was more irritating than funny. Now I won't rewatch that episode again, lol! 

Last week for science I did that rewatch! Now for science  I will watch next episode with the experiment method as an upon, lol! Observation, data collecting, and so one until the conclusion: shamy love is bulletproof, Ramona was like an inerte in a chemical reaction: none contribution to the final reaction result, hehe!

I have always liked that episode. Apparently I am in the minority. I thought Sheldon somehow getting himself in a relationship without even realizing it was hysterical. And I still do. He was so clueless back then.

I think when she comes back, he talks about Amy all the time because he remembers the relationship she forced him into and is telling her hey I am in a relationship now, I don't want one with you. He thinks that is enough but obviously he is completely oblivious to Ramona because he feels since he told her all about Amy, she knows he isn't interested so he just wants to be friends. Still clueless.....I am hoping still funny like then.

When Penny points out that Ramona is still interested and compares him to a mint in box toy he immediately says well I've been played with(we know figuratively and literally...LOL). He thinks it is taken care of and bam! Look Ramona is interested and doesn't care about Amy in any way shape or form.

We don't know if Ramona has been following Sheldon since she was kicked out of his life but my guess is she has. She may have been harboring feelings all this time and saw the relationship had a break the year before and wants to see if it would be possible again. Maybe she is one of the 200 people they have following FWF and she saw the meltdown he had. We have no idea what her thinking is but we all know we hate it because Shamy is so strong.

I actually hope Ramona is in the 1st episode next season so Amy can come back and give her a piece of her mind after Sheldon tells her what happened. I don't think he will keep it a secret(The writers wouldn't do that again, right?) So I think he tells her, we get a great engagement and a quick wedding. We know Sheldon doesn't want a long drawn out engagement.  Maybe they find a courthouse in NJ to get married at.(I can see it and I personally think they should do it like that). They come back married and Amy says to Ramona "How do you like that?"

Okay enough dreaming....come on Thursday.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

10 hours ago, snapepans said:

This post got me so confused. But I want to discuss this. 

1. "bachelor" means "not in a romantic relationship with someone", right?  So, no, Sheldon is NOT a bachelor.

 

I am only quoting this part to answer your question. The rest of the post I completely agree with. Bachelor technically means never married which Sheldon has never been. He is however in a committed relationship with Amy which we all know so Ramona should back off. She obviously is one of those women who could care less. He isn't fair game at all....she just feels that way since he is not married, even though that doesn't stop some women too.

[[Spoilers] Discussion: Season 10]

11 minutes ago, Stephen Hawking said:

According to Sheldon, his high bone density prevents him from swimming.

Amy: Why don’t we do something athletic like go over to the university pool and play water polo?

Leonard: No good, Sheldon doesn’t float.

Sheldon: That is true. I have a higher than normal body density. If I run too deep a bath, I drown.

 

I think it is more he can't float not he can't swim. Even so it still makes no sense.

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

I woke up this morning and debated whether to check for news or not. I was one of the optimistic ones but I still wasn't expecting this. I am at work currently and trying hard to concentrate on my task. I have my door locked so the boss can't come in without my knowledge first. I am a bit distracted. I love reading all the good things that have happened and the predictions for next season.

I do hope that Sheldon tells her exactly what happened and the reason he came because he just didn't want the same thing to happen to her that happened to him.(i.e. not knowing Ramona's intentions) He better be honest about the kiss. I don't think she will be mad at him and I sure hope Ramona is no where near Caltech when the wrath of Amy gets back.

I am still a bit in shock and I am so glad to have this forum so I can share in the news. I want to keep this to myself and not spoil anyone else so I am glad there are spoiled people to celebrate with.

 

[[Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10]

11 minutes ago, Kathy2611 said:

JFC....such a lame storyline (Ramona chasing after SC romantically and him yet again, being clueless)!!  I don't know who said it earlier but I like the one that was suggested it was a "scientifically cheating" storyline that would be much more plausible and believable than what it sounds like is going to play out.  Lame and predictable and not at all believable IF it looks like Sheldon would possibly (sexually) cheat on Amy.  If that is what they're going for, the backlash is going to be MASSIVE!  Not just from shippers but even the casual viewers aren't going to buy i

This part especially. I told my mom, who is a fan, about Ramona and what everyone was worried about. She said Sheldon cheating would be  so out of character for him. So even a casual viewer would hate it and not buy into it.

I for one am not worried and if it is another clueless Sheldon so be it. This is the story they seem to want to keep telling and we keep going back for more. I can't wait to hear exactly what happens and know that we had nothing to be worried about. TPTB do not want to lose a majority of their audience with another cheating storyline. Sheldon cheating would make many stop viewing in my opinion. I know there would be no going back for me.

 I just don't see it happening.