Jump to content

Season 5 finale SPOILERS.


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 73
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

don't think Zack is the only one that would "steal" Amy away from Sheldon, she can't be patient forever, remember her date with Stuart?

There's a bit of difference, Amy was not 'officially' in a relationship with Sheldon at the time when Stuart asked her out but now she is. So she would actually have to break up with him before going out with anyone else, which is a more drastic thing to do, and she wouldn't do it unless and until she's seriously dissatisfied with him. Clearly she feels a significant emotional attachment towards him.

But I agree that Sheldon does need to step up in more ways than one, if he really intends to keep Amy happy long-term.

Considering Sheldon was forced into a romantic relationship with Amy he's not doing anything different and if Amy really wanted to date Sheldon she should've said something to him before she went out with Stuart.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

don't think Zack is the only one that would "steal" Amy away from Sheldon, she can't be patient forever, remember her date with Stuart?

There's a bit of difference, Amy was not 'officially' in a relationship with Sheldon at the time when Stuart asked her out but now she is. So she would actually have to break up with him before going out with anyone else, which is a more drastic thing to do, and she wouldn't do it unless and until she's seriously dissatisfied with him. Clearly she feels a significant emotional attachment towards him.

But I agree that Sheldon does need to step up in more ways than one, if he really intends to keep Amy happy long-term.

Considering Sheldon was forced into a romantic relationship with Amy he's not doing anything different and if Amy really wanted to date Sheldon she should've said something to him before she went out with Stuart.

Where did that come from? Who do you think 'forced' him to be with her?

I'm sure Amy did inform him about her date. But she wasn't obliged to ask him, since they were not a couple.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

don't think Zack is the only one that would "steal" Amy away from Sheldon, she can't be patient forever, remember her date with Stuart?

There's a bit of difference, Amy was not 'officially' in a relationship with Sheldon at the time when Stuart asked her out but now she is. So she would actually have to break up with him before going out with anyone else, which is a more drastic thing to do, and she wouldn't do it unless and until she's seriously dissatisfied with him. Clearly she feels a significant emotional attachment towards him.

But I agree that Sheldon does need to step up in more ways than one, if he really intends to keep Amy happy long-term.

Considering Sheldon was forced into a romantic relationship with Amy he's not doing anything different and if Amy really wanted to date Sheldon she should've said something to him before she went out with Stuart.

Where did that come from? Who do you think 'forced' him to be with her?

I'm sure Amy did inform him about her date. But she wasn't obliged to ask him, since they were not a couple.

We the whole gang and Penny told him to get off his butt. If amy felt that way about she should've asked Sheldon out first before going out with stuart if she felt so strongly about Sheldon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sheldon wasn't 'forced' to do anything. Except act directly on his feelings. His normal attempt to manipulate things to his liking failed when Penny wouldn't play along with his scheme to make Amy jealous. He could have gone home and let Amy's date with Stuart run it's course. He chose to intervene, and he chose to propose to Amy that they change the paradigm of their relationship.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did the guys and Penny drag him to the movies to see Amy? No, but he didn't care that Amy went on a date with Stuart and Penny told him to go admit you like Amy, she might not had "forced" him, but she made him acknowledge them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest I'm not dead Cheryl

Did the guys and Penny drag him to the movies to see Amy? No, but he didn't care that Amy went on a date with Stuart and Penny told him to go admit you like Amy, she might not had "forced" him, but she made him acknowledge them.

He said he didn't care because he thought that Amy wouldn't go out with Stuart "what would Amy find in an impobrished pecker of picture books" were his words.

When he went to the comic book store with Leonard and found out she did go out with Stuart (because no, Amy did not tell him, he found out she went out on the date with Stuart when Dale said so at the comic book store) he did look very sad and troubled even if he said he was "ok". He kept talking about his future Nobel prize, cities named after him and his wisdom teeth, but nothing about his emotional state that was what Leonard was asking him (btw: changing the subject is totally a sign that he was indeed, not "OK" at all).

He was stalking Stuart's facebook profile even before Leonard told him to confront his feelings for Amy, so, he DID do it by himself, no one pressured him to do anything he didn't want to.

Saying that his friends or Amy "forced" him to ask her to be his girlfriend is totally wrong. The whole episode was making a point on how he was the one who was jealous and decided to claim Amy as his girfriend so she wouldn't go out with anyone else.

sometimes I wonder if we are watching the same show.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think everyone forgets that sheldon is human and he does have feelings so he is perfectly capable of asking amy to be his girlfriend not because his friends or amy pressured him into doing it but because he has feelings for her.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did the guys and Penny drag him to the movies to see Amy? No, but he didn't care that Amy went on a date with Stuart and Penny told him to go admit you like Amy, she might not had "forced" him, but she made him acknowledge them.

He said he didn't care because he thought that Amy wouldn't go out with Stuart "what would Amy find in an impobrished pecker of picture books" were his words.

When he went to the comic book store with Leonard and found out she did go out with Stuart (because no, Amy did not tell him, he found out she went out on the date with Stuart when Dale said so at the comic book store) he did look very sad and troubled even if he said he was "ok". He kept talking about his future Nobel prize, cities named after him and his wisdom teeth, but nothing about his emotional state that was what Leonard was asking him (btw: changing the subject is totally a sign that he was indeed, not "OK" at all).

He was stalking Stuart's facebook profile even before Leonard told him to confront his feelings for Amy, so, he DID do it by himself, no one pressured him to do anything he didn't want to.

Saying that his friends or Amy "forced" him to ask her to be his girlfriend is totally wrong. The whole episode was making a point on how he was the one who was jealous and decided to claim Amy as his girfriend so she wouldn't go out with anyone else.

sometimes I wonder if we are watching the same show.

Yes he was jealous but at the same time didn't care that she went out with Stuart until Penny told him to go do something and it's not like amy ever asked out Sheldon and he rejected her, if she felt that way she should've asked him instead of throwing Stuart into the mix.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we want to go down this road, Penny convinced Amy to accept the date with Stuart in the first place.

Yes, she did. Penny has never been shy about her feelings about Sheldon as boyfriend material for Amy. Btw, Penny's opinions on this make wonder how anyone can think she would ever see him as relationship material for herself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we want to go down this road, Penny convinced Amy to accept the date with Stuart in the first place.

Yes, she did. Penny has never been shy about her feelings about Sheldon as boyfriend material for Amy. Btw, Penny's opinions on this make wonder how anyone can think she would ever see him as relationship material for herself.

See that as a really baddddd "Lab Accident" IMO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cbolt, how can Sheldon be jealous AND not care that Amy went out with Stuart? It is the fact that she did so that made him jealous.


If we want to go down this road, Penny convinced Amy to accept the date with Stuart in the first place.

Yes, she did. Penny has never been shy about her feelings about Sheldon as boyfriend material for Amy. Btw, Penny's opinions on this make wonder how anyone can think she would ever see him as relationship material for herself.

See that as a really baddddd "Lab Accident" IMO

True! Oh, so true!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's because Penny thinks of Sheldon as a whack a doo which has nothing to do if she wants him and Amy as a couple. HeWolf if Amy really wanted Sheldon she should've asked him out first and not drag Stuart in the middle, it is 2012 women can asks guys out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dragging Stuart in? HE asked her out. She's probably never asked a guy out in her life.

If she likes Sheldon that bad she should've asked him how he feels and not leading on Stuart.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest I'm not dead Cheryl

Dragging Stuart in? HE asked her out. She's probably never asked a guy out in her life.

If she likes Sheldon that bad she should've asked him how he feels and not leading on Stuart.

because he is Sheldon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In the comic book store ,when sheldon found out that amy actually went out with stuart ,you could clearly see that he has jealous as he changes the subject to his teeth and IQ

Also when leonard asked sheldon if he was alright with stuart asking amy out,sheldon didn't actually give a straight awnser.

Amy doesn't seem like the kind of person that just asks people out.Stuart asked her out!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also when leonard asked sheldon if he was alright with stuart asking amy out,sheldon didn't actually give a straight awnser.

Yup... Sheldon never gets beyond the "fact" that Amy would never go out with Stuart. In his mind, it was a pointless question. Although, as we have seen demonstrated on a regular basis, Sheldon is quite wrong on a great many things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I completely agree with Sursonica (as usual) and HeWolf above.

(And psst, Sursonica - bit of grammar Nazi here - that was 'impoverished peddler of picture books''). :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

LOL I totally spelled that wrong and I knew it but was too lazy to correct it :)

No problem at all. I'm just a bit sensitive about the accuracy of Sheldon quotes. :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.