Ship Zone [Spoilers] Shamy: Season 9

[jenafan]

I don't think the RA is skewed in Sheldon's favor. There's plenty of stuff on there that you could never imagine him coming up with on his own. Yes, he tries to find loopholes when he doesn't like something, but so does Amy at the end of the day. It's also clear nothing goes in the RA or is amended without both parties agreement (hence their committee meetings, lol). Actually, Amy has brought up the RA or used it to her advantage more often than Sheldon in the last couple of seasons. That's kind of what would be interesting about it not being brought up yet; if Amy were using the bureaucracy loopholes better than Sheldon because he's so desperate fixated on how to get her back he's not even thinking about the RA. He would find that so hot when he finds out how he was being fooled 

I love this line.  Sheldon would be all into that...

I also love everyone's idea that Amy is not mentioning the RA agreement on purpose and to her advantage because the break up is not "official" and she doesn't want it to be.   She is just still trying to get her space....

[Arduina]

 He would find that so hot when he finds out how he was being fooled 

Oh yeah Can't wait

[koops]

I kind of would picture his reaction to be like the one he had over her overnight kits in his apartment. 

 

  

[DoctorWhat]

My opinion is that they are not really thinking about the agreement.Amy is clearly angree,ahe doesn't want to see him and Sheldon is desperate and worried this is for real (or he wouldn't be acting like that) so I believe none of them cares about the RA at this point.Maybe when they calm down they'll mention it,Sheldon will I suppose but that's later.About dating,I would like to see both dating other people.Especially Sheldon,because he has never done this sort of stuff before (with other women I mean).I think it will be very interesting seeing him dating just to make Amy jealous,I don't think he would date for another reason anyway,and messing this up so badly.I mean imagine,a woman accepts to go out with him because he is tall and cute with blue eyes (fangirling) and then he starts talking and she leaves:p

[Luna18]

JMHO, I certainly don't want to see them dating other people. I feel like the writers can come up with a quirky, Shamy-style way to get them back together. I want tptb to think outside of the box.

I think they can achieve that. I've feeling much more positive and trustful of the writers again after what CaffeineBuzz and Kerry said about the first two episodes they saw as well as the new spoiler from EW 

It's funny how quickly the overall mood in this forum changed from depressed and angry to hopeful and excited just like that 

 

[Desdemona]

I kind of would picture his reaction to be like the one he had over her overnight kits in his apartment. 

 

  

I love this smile, it´s my screensaver on my mobile phone!

Edited August 23, 2015 by Desdemona

[jenafan]

Back to the ring, I can see Amy being absolutely enamored if Sheldon presented it to her as a family ring.   The women in Sheldon's life, his Meemaw and his mother are very dear to him and set the example of keeping a marriage together in spite of obstacles.   How significant it would be that he wants his little lady to carry on a part of that history?   Sheldon was caressing that ring box at the end as if the ring was already precious to him, just as Amy is.   I still believe that ring was gold, and silver is the style of today, giving credence that the ring is an heirloom.    Sheldon knows Amy loves vintage, and she will adore it.

While a store bought ring that Sheldon picked out on his own would be meaningful as well, I don't see this as being IC for Sheldon. 

I am inclined to believe that Sheldon asked his mother for the ring or received it after discussing with Mary his intentions sometime around the Mom's episode after the night with Amy in the Fort.   It would coincide with all the discussion about engagement rings in that episode and the obsession over commitment and Lenny's setting a marriage date in the finale.   It was definitely on his mind.

Sheldon was spending a lot of time on his laptop while Lenny was debating over their wedding date.  Perhaps this was when he was making the SF reservations, that I do believe were meant for him and Amy.  Perhaps this is what he wanted to discuss with her during the Skype call at the end, that he had been thinking about relationships and that he wanted her to go away with him..... 

I want to add, that I love reading every ones' speculations, because I find sometimes I like others' ideas better than my own.

Edited August 23, 2015 by jenafan

[koops]

My opinion is that they are not really thinking about the agreement.Amy is clearly angree,ahe doesn't want to see him and Sheldon is desperate and worried this is for real (or he wouldn't be acting like that) so I believe none of them cares about the RA at this point.Maybe when they calm down they'll mention it,Sheldon will I suppose but that's later.About dating,I would like to see both dating other people.Especially Sheldon,because he has never done this sort of stuff before (with other women I mean).I think it will be very interesting seeing him dating just to make Amy jealous,I don't think he would date for another reason anyway,and messing this up so badly.I mean imagine,a woman accepts to go out with him because he is tall and cute with blue eyes (fangirling) and then he starts talking and she leaves:p

I am saying why the writers are not writing in the agreement, not the characters. It seems odd, given that is the cornerstone of this relationship they came up with, that they haven't found a way for it to be brought up at all over the last three episodes. 

As for them dating other people, that pretty much destroys everything that is special about Shamy. The whole point that sets them apart from other people is that they ARE each other's firsts and only. You take that away, have them date other people, like every normal couple out there, and they're just that: any normal couple out there. Plus, they have had Sheldon be on unrequited dates plenty of times before, in S1 when he unknowingly stole Raj's girlfriend, and when he was his wingman with Martha and that other girl. Been there, done that. The point of Amy was precisely to get Sheldon in a relationship and see how he would navigate it. They are not Leonard and Penny, or any other couple on this show or any other show. I personally have no interest in watching the same old recycled stuff that I can see in any other show on TV. Not to mention it would turn the whole thing into a giant soap opera: dating, jealousy, angry fits and fight. 

[A Shamy gal]

Sheldon was spending a lot of time on his laptop while Lenny was debating over their wedding date.  Perhaps this was when he was making the SF reservations, that I do believe were meant for him and Amy.  Perhaps this is what he wanted to discuss with her during the Skype call at the end, that he had been thinking about relationships and that he wanted her to go away with him..... 

I thought he spent a lot of time on his laptop trying to get in contact with Amy, but she was ignoring him until she was ready to speak to him.

[jenafan]

I think you are right, Shamy gal.

[LeaGold]

I had a thought about if a marriage comes up for them. Maybe if he decided not to do a marriage agreement or something he would take the vow literally as something of a contract he speaks in front of others. Maybe his vows would be the pseudo marriage agreement in short and such. Along with him affirming he loves her and what not. 

[Arduina]

I had a thought about if a marriage comes up for them. Maybe if he decided not to do a marriage agreement or something he would take the vow literally as something of a contract he speaks in front of others. Maybe his vows would be the pseudo marriage agreement in short and such. Along with him affirming he loves her and what not. 

I really could picture that

[Kathy2611]

About dating,I would like to see both dating other people.Especially Sheldon,because he has never done this sort of stuff before (with other women I mean).I think it will be very interesting seeing him dating just to make Amy jealous,I don't think he would date for another reason anyway,and messing this up so badly.I mean imagine,a woman accepts to go out with him because he is tall and cute with blue eyes (fangirling) and then he starts talking and she leaves:p

No offense but this is just the stupidest thing the writers could do!  Like Koops said, yes he has dated other girls before (he might not have realized it but he did).  The result....he wasn't interested in doing it a second time with any of them and Martha he did only because Raj gave him the hulk hands to do a second one.

And to only date another girl to make Amy jealous is stupid and childish and it's been done (or tried) before when he asked Penny out on a date.

And also, like Koops said, them dating others would literally destroy the uniqueness of Shamy and reads like a bad fanfic.  Well the one I'm thinking of that's out there, the author has excellent writing talent but she basically destroyed Shamy and wrote them both so pathetically out of character, I couldn't stomach it.  And I wouldn't stomach watching it play out on the show either.

Edited August 23, 2015 by Kathy2611

[Desdemona]

I want him to look like that, if he ever finds out about Amy´s fanfiction and reads it.

[rachelshamyfan]

I'd love for Meemaw to appear as well

Sheldon talks so fondly of her that I just want to see how he is around her and how proud he likes to show off Amy as he did with professor proton

[loriparis80]

I'd love for Meemaw to appear as well

Sheldon talks so fondly of her that I just want to see how he is around her and how proud he likes to show off Amy as he did with professor proton

Yes, I wish so much for this to happen.

[mirs1]

Not to mention that it would be highly unaffective to try to make Amy jelous with other women...How could she possibly believe that the same guy that barely kisses her after five years suddently becomes a "ladies man"?!? Look what has happened  with the bra in the box, he got a WTF look and Amy was angrier and angrier. And I think that the fact that it was Penny's and Amy knew it was not very relevant for her reaction; even if she didn't recognize it, for sure she wouldn't have believed that Sheldon had some businness in common with other girls' bra!

It is hard enough to deal with the "incident" never to be mentioned again...let's other possible partners remain just subjects for fanfictions, so that people can choose if reading them or not!!!

[Susana Alcira]

I am saying why the writers are not writing in the agreement, not the characters. It seems odd, given that is the cornerstone of this relationship they came up with, that they haven't found a way for it to be brought up at all over the last three episodes. 

As for them dating other people, that pretty much destroys everything that is special about Shamy. The whole point that sets them apart from other people is that they ARE each other's firsts and only. You take that away, have them date other people, like every normal couple out there, and they're just that: any normal couple out there. Plus, they have had Sheldon be on unrequited dates plenty of times before, in S1 when he unknowingly stole Raj's girlfriend, and when he was his wingman with Martha and that other girl. Been there, done that. The point of Amy was precisely to get Sheldon in a relationship and see how he would navigate it. They are not Leonard and Penny, or any other couple on this show or any other show. I personally have no interest in watching the same old recycled stuff that I can see in any other show on TV. Not to mention it would turn the whole thing into a giant soap opera: dating, jealousy, angry fits and fight. 

No offense but this is just the stupidest thing the writers could do!  Like Koops said, yes he has dated other girls before (he might not have realized it but he did).  The result....he wasn't interested in doing it a second time with any of them and Martha he did only because Raj gave him the hulk hands to do a second one.

And to only date another girl to make Amy jealous is stupid and childish and it's been done (or tried) before when he asked Penny out on a date.

And also, like Koops said, them dating others would literally destroy the uniqueness of Shamy and reads like a bad fanfic.  Well the one I'm thinking of that's out there, the author has excellent writing talent but she basically destroyed Shamy and wrote them both so pathetically out of character, I couldn't stomach it.  And I wouldn't stomach watching it play out on the show either.

Totally agree! I say again and again: SHAMY is Unique! All love things are for the FIRST TIME for both of them!

(Plse Kathy2611, don´t name that bad FF again! Hope the writers haven´t read it)

[rachelshamyfan]

What story is that?

[Arduina]

I still think that a very funny thing would be a girl trying to get him to notice her / date her because she knows he's now single, while he'll still be Sheldon being Sheldon and not getting a thing. Amy seeing this and somehow hearing him tell the girl Amy's the only one he could ever love because Penny or Leonard had told him what the girl really wants.

Could be a key moment for Amy to rethink her break-up decision.

Meeting Meamaw, I've been requesting this for one full year BUT I don't want her to get involved into getting them back together. If this has to last 3 to 6 episodes, then I want Sheldon to figure it out all by himself. And THEN he'll be able to introduce Amy as his fiancée

 

Geez ... the possibilities !!!!

Oh and I want Sheldon to tell her as they reconcile "Now, before this goes any further, you should know that all forms of physical contact up to and including coitus are so not off the table."

[DoctorWhat]

I didn't say he would be actually interested in other women,nor did I mean that Amy would actually be jealous,this would never work.I just think you could do it because as I hear he went to the pathetic means of putting Penny's bra in a box to make Amy jealous.I don't see how a date is worse than that.What I didn't remember is that he had other dates,perhaps because I don't think of them as such,I don't know.I still think it would be funny anyway.The whole "first and only" thing doesn't appeal to me at all,that's why I'd liked it changed. That fanfiction you mentioned though...no idea

[mphs95]

No offense but this is just the stupidest thing the writers could do!  Like Koops said, yes he has dated other girls before (he might not have realized it but he did).  The result....he wasn't interested in doing it a second time with any of them and Martha he did only because Raj gave him the hulk hands to do a second one.

And to only date another girl to make Amy jealous is stupid and childish and it's been done (or tried) before when he asked Penny out on a date.

And also, like Koops said, them dating others would literally destroy the uniqueness of Shamy and reads like a bad fanfic.  Well the one I'm thinking of that's out there, the author has excellent writing talent but she basically destroyed Shamy and wrote them both so pathetically out of character, I couldn't stomach it.  And I wouldn't stomach watching it play out on the show either.

I happen to agree with you but don't bite a person's head off. It is his/her opinion and they should feel comfortable expressing it. This goes for everyone here. I may not agree with all the opinions here but I try to respect them without being mean. No I am not trying to start anything. I just want our forum to be one where we can sometimes agree to disagree without fear is all. Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

[Kathy2611]

What story is that?

The New Beginning Experiment

[rachelshamyfan]

Oh I like that one

Sometimes different is good and there's not many where shamy completely break up and go off with other partners

[tallin]

No offense but this is just the stupidest thing the writers could do!  Like Koops said, yes he has dated other girls before (he might not have realized it but he did).  The result....he wasn't interested in doing it a second time with any of them and Martha he did only because Raj gave him the hulk hands to do a second one.

And to only date another girl to make Amy jealous is stupid and childish and it's been done (or tried) before when he asked Penny out on a date.

And also, like Koops said, them dating others would literally destroy the uniqueness of Shamy and reads like a bad fanfic.  Well the one I'm thinking of that's out there, the author has excellent writing talent but she basically destroyed Shamy and wrote them both so pathetically out of character, I couldn't stomach it.  And I wouldn't stomach watching it play out on the show either.

Yeah, I had same experience even while with different story. Author with huge potential, good start and then I felt like characters were just replaced for someone else. So no. If someone wants different Shamy, there is ff for that, if someone is into that, but let's keep our real Shamy- Shamy.