Ship Zone [Spoilers] Shamy: Season 10

[I Miss Dan]

Yae here.

[Desdemona]

1 hour ago, April said:

A few weeks ago I offered to do a "Top 10 Shamy Moments of S10" - if you guys want me to I can organise the whole thing. Y/N??

Big Yes! Although I don´t know how much time I will need to decide which scene are going to make it into my Top 10. When it comes to Shamy, I´m as indecisive and struggling as Sheldon.

How is that possible, that I ran out of likes for today?! I haven´t had time to like much.

[kimbee73]

3 hours ago, April said:

A few weeks ago I offered to do a "Top 10 Shamy Moments of S10" - if you guys want me to I can organise the whole thing. Y/N??

Yes!!

[April]

1 hour ago, April said:

Well, who can resist this cute little lump of wool!? :D

Some logistical questions:

This is about your favourite moments of S10 ! We all know what a great season it was so are 10 enough or you or shall we go 15?

Also, how much time do you guys need to decide? Is one week enough or do you need two??

I thought about doing it like Tensor did last year with everybody sending in their rankings and I'll tally them up and post the countdown afterwards and we can all gush about how great this season was for our cuties!

Anything else?

Not that I don't appreciate everybody's likes on this post but I'd actually like some answers to these questions! The earlier we clear this up the earlier we can start!! :D

[spidergirl]

2 hours ago, April said:

Well, who can resist this cute little lump of wool!? :D

Some logistical questions:

This is about your favourite moments of S10 ! We all know what a great season it was so are 10 enough or you or shall we go 15?

Also, how much time do you guys need to decide? Is one week enough or do you need two??

I thought about doing it like Tensor did last year with everybody sending in their rankings and I'll tally them up and post the countdown afterwards and we can all gush about how great this season was for our cuties!

Anything else?

I vote in 10, for avoid some chaos in my head, lol. I also vote in two weeks. For now I have not more questions/sugestions.

[Jonny]

My take is IMO do a ranking of Season 10 Shamy moments and see how that goes. Then if there is an appetite for doing something more comprehensive (all seasons) or focusing on specific things then perhaps explore it.

The Season 10 Shamy moments should be easier and fresh in the minds of people.

Top 10 or 15 I would be comfortable with, 20 seems a lot. Whatever you feel comfortable with April if you are willing to put the time in to run something like this and keep us sane during the long break lol. Perhaps top 10 might be the easiest?

Final episode airs this week in the UK so we may get some who want to participate then. So say next week or the week after?

Edited May 15, 2017 by Jonny

[Kathy2611]

We might need to send a medic to the spoiler free thread.  We haven't heard from anybody since 10.23 aired.

[Jonny]

9 minutes ago, Kathy2611 said:

We might need to send a medic to the spoiler free thread.  We haven't heard from anybody since 10.23 aired.

I think a lot have sadly moved on. 22 pages on that thread last season, 5 this year. Don't see a lot of those users post anymore.

Not everyone loved the finale and had built in their heads the proposal being very different judging from elsewhere.

Edited May 15, 2017 by Jonny

[April]

5 minutes ago, Kathy2611 said:

We might need to send a medic to the spoiler free thread.  We haven't heard from anybody since 10.23 aired.

See, this is why I read spoilers to prepare myself - those poor chaps didn't know what hit 'em!!

[kimbee73]

29 minutes ago, April said:

Not that I don't appreciate everybody's likes on this post but I'd actually like some answers to these questions! The earlier we clear this up the earlier we can start!! :D

I think ten is more than enough....although I could easily find 15.

I think no more than two weeks  should be sufficient time if rewatches are necessary to make final decisions.

I like the idea of tallying up the results and doing a countdown is a great idea. You could put one up a day and surprise us.

Seriously if you need help I would be happy to help also.

[spidergirl]

25 minutes ago, Kathy2611 said:

We might need to send a medic to the spoiler free thread.  We haven't heard from anybody since 10.23 aired.

That's  why I am not unspoiled anymore.  It was enough to me the psicological torture I suffered for s8 hiatus.  I am too young for getting brain damages, lol! 

[Tensor]

40 minutes ago, Jonny said:

My take is IMO do a ranking of Season 10 Shamy moments and see how that goes. Then if there is an appetite for doing something more comprehensive (all seasons) or focusing on specific things then perhaps explore it.

The Season 10 Shamy moments should be easier and fresh in the minds of people.

Top 10 or 15 I would be comfortable with, 20 seems a lot. Whatever you feel comfortable with April if you are willing to put the time in to run something like this and keep us sane during the long break lol. Perhaps top 10 might be the easiest?

Final episode airs this week in the UK so we may get some who want to participate then. So say next week or the week after?

We do a top ten All seasons list, with the number one being posted the night of the first taping.  If you want my methodology, for the season list, drop me a PM. 

[Judith]

I agree on top ten. 

[April]

6 minutes ago, Tensor said:

We do a top ten All seasons list, with the number one being posted the night of the first taping.  If you want my methodology, for the season list, drop me a PM. 

Yeah, that was the inspiration for this - but it'll only cover S10 as a nice way to cap off the season thread.

Do you already know when you'll open the S11 forum?

[Tensor]

8 minutes ago, April said:

Yeah, that was the inspiration for this - but it'll only cover S10 as a nice way to cap off the season thread.

Do you already know when you'll open the S11 forum?

See PM.  

[April]

4 minutes ago, Tensor said:

See PM.  

Thank you! <3

[mirs1]

1 hour ago, Kathy2611 said:

We might need to send a medic to the spoiler free thread.  We haven't heard from anybody since 10.23 aired.

Judging from what I've seen elsewhere on the internet,  many un-spoiled fans were pretty disappointed in the way Sheldon proposed, probably that's why they are not writing here...

[spidergirl]

22 minutes ago, mirs1 said:

Judging from what I've seen elsewhere on the internet,  many un-spoiled fans were pretty disappointed in the way Sheldon proposed, probably that's why they are not writing here...

What intrigues me more is it seems all of  the unspoiled fans got disappointed. It would be interisting to read why they got disappointed though. 

[Capt. Hilts]

2 minutes ago, spidergirl said:

What intrigues me more is it seems all of  the unspoiled fans got disappointed. It would be interisting to read why they got disappointed though. 

There's really no way to make that conclusion about "unspoiled" fans who are not here.

Indeed, experience suggests otherwise.  Discussion boards attract the angry and disaffected - without regard to topic - politics, sports, films, whatever. 

Edited May 15, 2017 by Capt. Hilts

[mirs1]

8 minutes ago, spidergirl said:

What intrigues me more is it seems all of  the unspoiled fans got disappointed. It would be interisting to read why they got disappointed though. 

Some of them thought Amy deserved a better proposal, without Ramona being involved. I kinds get this complaint, even if I loved so much the last montage and the actual proposal, so overall I'm not dissatisfied.

6 minutes ago, Capt. Hilts said:

There's really no way to make that conclusion about "unspoiled" fans who are not here.

Indeed, discussion boards attract the angry and disaffected - without regard to topic - politics, sports, films, whatever. 

The persons I'm referring to write also in this forum.

Edited May 15, 2017 by mirs1

[spidergirl]

17 minutes ago, Capt. Hilts said:

There's really no way to make that conclusion about "unspoiled" fans who are not here.

Indeed, experience suggests otherwise.  Discussion boards attract the angry and disaffected - without regard to topic - politics, sports, films, whatever. 

I said " it seems" so it is a suspicious feeling, not a conclusion. Besides I was not  only speaking about those from here but I am speaking about unspoiled fans in general, as I have not met one that was unspoiled and happy about the season finale . Where? IG and Tumblr.  But just a litle few speak load why they got disapointed. Just my opinion. No intention of getting to angry or offended kind of conversation. Just an observation from me as a fan.

[Soopysue]

A few weeks ago I offered to do a "Top 10 Shamy Moments of S10" - if you guys want me to I can organise the whole thing. Y/N??

Yes please [emoji8]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Érika Souza]

5 hours ago, April said:

A few weeks ago I offered to do a "Top 10 Shamy Moments of S10" - if you guys want me to I can organise the whole thing. Y/N??

Yeeees, pleeaasee!

[Jonny]

1 hour ago, mirs1 said:

Some of them thought Amy deserved a better proposal, without Ramona being involved. I kinds get this complaint, even if I loved so much the last montage and the actual proposal, so overall I'm not dissatisfied.

The persons I'm referring to write also in this forum.

I get that a bit, it was not at all what I had envisioned for them or had hoped for. But the storyline they went with was executed and acted so well (also taking into account 10.23 a clear setup storyline for the finale) it still is an incredible moment. I think some of those people wanted something more clear cut 'this is what it is and why now' and less ambiguous.

But it's also a half told story in a way, the other half could be the sweetest, most enjoyable part of it.

On a separate note with all the discussion about Shamy top 10's I am going to find it very very hard to decide where to place it in my top 10 because of what I said, it's not resolved. It won't be my no.1 moment for the season, I know that lol.

Edited May 15, 2017 by Jonny

[BigBangEnthusiast]

1 hour ago, mirs1 said:

Judging from what I've seen elsewhere on the internet,  many un-spoiled fans were pretty disappointed in the way Sheldon proposed, probably that's why they are not writing here...

I was unspoiled for most of the season. When I watched the finale, I felt numb when it ended. I was upset by the whole Ramona involvement. The worst was that horrible kiss. I write fanfiction, and of all the possible scenarios I could have dreamed of for a catalyst to a proposal, never in a million years would this have even crossed my mind.

When I re-watched the episode, I felt better about the situation. I love that Sheldon got on a plane and went to Amy. It was very romantic.