episodes 1010 'The Property Division Collision' (December 1)

[Tripper]

'The Property Division Collision' - Season 10, Episode 10 
Airs Thursday, December 1 at 8/7c on CBS.

Sheldon and Leonard try to divvy up their shared belongings, but can't agree on anything. Also, Koothrappali and Stuart fight to be the most helpful during Bernadette's final weeks of pregnancy.

[Judith]

I liked the Shamy interactions. That's all I've got.

[Chrismo]

Okay episode. Sheldon being an ass nothing new. Would like to see Leonard win one for once. raj Stuart storyline didn't need to see. Should of been at least s little more realistic with Bernadette's water breaking.

[3ku11]

Pretty solid episode. I laughed 75% most of it. I don't think the Raj and Stuart storyline was uneccessary. I thought it was hilarous tbh. Them both fighting to be the third party in the Howardette relationship. Stuart and Raj are basically the equivalent to what Sheldon is to Lenny tbh. Stuart was hilarous at the beggining, oh yeah my car broke down so how about now? I might be here , till your daughter goes to college lol.  I felt Johnny stole the show for me. IF it wasen't his expressions. OR him wrapped up in the flag hahaha. He just really shone. And Penny had Leonard's side, I knew she would. Give her some some credit huh. Called Sheldon an ass at least three times lol. I did like when Leonard was like at the beggining of the episode. Take it all. You could hear Penny in the background, going Leonard... With such a caring tone. I liked that. Was interesting in the end when Lenny were positioning the painting. Leonard and Penny are the same height lol! Kinda cute haha. I did like the reference when Penny was like, wanna go for a jog? And Leonard's like nah better not, last time the old lady was like watch out behind you LOL. I really liked Christopher Llyods subtle role in this too. He was pretty funny, just some guy who got a great oppurtunity to live at this great Apt. Making himself at home, then making Shelnard see sense. The episode did remind me sort of The Panty Pinata Polirization. When Sheldon walked into the Laundry Mat, this time it was Leonard he was sparring with. Overall not a earth shattering episode. But consistent with the level of quality Season Ten has been delivering on. I well give it a Good. 

48 minutes ago, Chrismo said:

Okay episode. Sheldon being an ass nothing new. Would like to see Leonard win one for once. raj Stuart storyline didn't need to see. Should of been at least s little more realistic with Bernadette's water breaking.

Let's be honest mate, what do us males know about the realism of a womens water breaking hahaha. 

Edited December 2, 2016 by 3ku11

[joyceraye]

49 minutes ago, 3ku11 said:

 

Let's be honest mate, what do us males know about the realism of a womens water breaking hahaha. 

Nobody mentioned the waters breaking in the version I saw. I watched it twice. I thought the Wolowitz house had the funnier of the interactions tonight. I was disappointed to see Sheldon's selfishness and possessiveness again. I thought he'd been softening up and getting a better sense of proportion lately, especially since living with Amy. Now here he is being a jerk again.

Edited December 2, 2016 by joyceraye
Snipping for space.

[john2p]

I have just watched it and I am deeply disappointed. I hadn´t any single laugh. The whole dividing sequence was cringeworthy. Christopher Lloyd wasn´t as funny as expected. And Raj-Stewart versus Howard-Bernadette, well I already wasn´t fond of in previous episodes. I won´t watch it again. 

[jenafan]

Unfortunately my TV screen went green during Shamy's conversation about the painting during the cold open.  I like seeing Sheldon as excited about the painting and PAmy's friendship as I am.  

Like two peas in a pod, both Amy and Sheldon being clueless about Penny's displeasure of getting the painting back reminded me how similar and quirky they really are.  I had to laugh when Amy remarked about Sheldon not knowing when he is not wanted.  Amy is just as bad sometimes.

I adored Sheldon telling Amy she was cute and watching Amy walk away flipping her hair and strutting her stuff.  

Vengeful Leonard was a nice welcome.  He pulled off the flag toga nicely.  He seems to be getting more and more comfortable dropping his drawers and shaking his hiney between the cap and gown, naughty carrot, dancing in his underwear, and now.

I enjoyed seeing Stuart and Raj fighting over being the 3rd wheel.  I personally like Stuart in the caretaker role.  I see him becoming a nanny for the baby like he did for Debbie.  This leaves Raj available to hang out with the group.

I love Spock but didn't care for the clock.

Back to the flag, I was surprised Sheldon made a big deal about it.  It belongs to 4A.  Sheldon and Amy can make a new one together for 4B.

I loved loved loved how when Leonard opened the apartment door and saw Theodore, he put his arm up to protect Penny from entering until he felt it was safe.

Theodore was great.  He called Sheldon Lenny's neighbor.  How sweet that he helped Shelnard realize the real problem regarding their separation anxiety.  Having Sheldon acknowledge that his part of the lease in 4A is up in a few weeks really does make the new LA permanent.

I can't wait to see how they all redecorate.  

I love the new direction with the Raj/Stuart competition and the PALS interaction.  

My only disappointment was that Howard tried to avoid Bernie when she called for him but staying on the couch and sending one of the other guys to her.  Also her announcement of being in possible labor seemed anti-climatic.  I did like the Rajuart team bump on the way to the hospital.

Finally, I thoroughly enjoyed each time Leonard knocked on the door of 4B and Sheldon answered.  The way Sheldon stood so tall against the open door calling out to/or standing next to Amy gave me so many wonderful feels!  4B is so them!

Sheldon may be out, but Lenny will never be free of him, and it doesn't seem like they really want to be either.  They just want their own place, not end their friendship.  

Penny implying the Shelnard pairing was factually comedic.  I loved it!

Edited December 2, 2016 by jenafan

[Chrismo]

7 minutes ago, john2p said:

I have just watched it and I am deeply disappointed. I hadn´t any single laugh. The whole dividing sequence was cringeworthy. Christopher Lloyd wasn´t as funny as expected. And Raj-Stewart versus Howard-Bernadette, well I already wasn´t fond of in previous episodes. I won´t watch it again. 

While I wasn't totally disappointed like you I do understand your sentiment. I wish the dividing was a little more realistic. Switching  couches for example. Didn't need to see the painting again. Didn't need Christopher Lloyd to point out the Shelnard bromance.

[john2p]

Maybe it´s because I stood up early to watch it, that I got a bad feeling about it. It´s 4:00 am and I had big expectations, because season 10 till now really shone to me.  And Christopher Lloyd is my childhood hero. So, I will give it a try again , when I am not having a grumpy feeling :P. But I never like this kind of a view on the Shelnard relationship. After all these years, even Sheldon (and thus Leonard) wouldn´t need to have a Theodor to call them out on the underlying brother feelings they have to eachother. In my eyes they should have fight with some lightness, and not this kind of fight. It´s like they evolved in everything, but their relationship. BTW The Lenny (and also the Shamy) were cute to eachother, with some little snarks. Maybe that´s what I mean, why can´t Shelnard be like that way, lighthearted and sure with some nasty comments. 

Edited December 2, 2016 by john2p

[Chrismo]

14 minutes ago, jenafan said:

 

Like two peas in a pod, both Amy and Sheldon being clueless about Penny's displeasure of getting the painting back reminded me how similar and quirky they really are.  

I adored Sheldon telling Amy she was cute and watching Amy walk away flipping her hair and strutting her stuff.  

 

I can't wait to see how they all redecorate.  

 

I respectfully disagree on these three points. there's a fine line between clueless and stupidity. IMO Shamy and the painting in regards to Penny's displeasure was stupidity

Amy flipping the hair  IMO was cringeworthy.

i hope they abandon the storyline in regards to the move . If I want to see redecorating I'll go watch HGTV.

[3ku11]

16 minutes ago, john2p said:

Maybe it´s because I stood up early to watch it, that I got a bad feeling about it. It´s 4:00 am and I had big expectations, because season 10 till now really shone to me.  And Christopher Lloyd is my childhood hero. So, I will give it a try, when I am not having a grumpy feeling :P. But I never like this kind of a view on the Shelnard relationship. After all these years, even Sheldon (and thus Leonard) wouldn´t need to have a Theodor to call them out on the underlying brother feelings they have to eachother. In my eyes they should have fight with some lightness, and not this kind of fight. It´s like they evolved in everything, but their relationship. BTW The Lenny (and also the Shamy) were cute to eachother, with some little snarks. Maybe that´s what I mean, why can´t Shelnard be like that way, lighthearted and sure with some nasty comments. 

Typical brothers, alot of snark, ton of fighting. But their is love their too. I see your point. But difference is I think Lenny and Shamy have more give or take. Shamy more take lol. But point is it is just typical tyrant Sheldon. Insufferable Sheldon. He is basically a big baby who needs to get his own way. Leonard lets him. It is only when it is made clear to Sheldon his behaviour is not okay, he seems to adapt. But he tends to degress at times too. 

6 minutes ago, Chrismo said:

I respectfully disagree on these three points. there's a fine line between clueless and stupidity. IMO Shamy and the painting in regards to Penny's displeasure was stupidity

Amy flipping the hair  IMO was cringeworthy.

i hope they abandon the storyline in regards to the move . If I want to see redecorating I'll go watch HGTV.

That is why it was funny. Shamy's indifference to Penny's displeasure, is what it funny. But that is just me. Same time happened in Season 5 or when ever we last saw it. Amy was clueless to Penny's displeasure. So basically continuity their.  I agree should of focused more on the couches or something. But it is done now, and the move seems permenant. So their is that. 

And I don't know I Thought Amy's hair flip was cute lol. But that is just me. 

Edited December 2, 2016 by 3ku11

[john2p]

1 minute ago, 3ku11 said:

Typical brothers, alot of snark, ton of fighting. But their is love their too. I see your point. But difference is I think Lenny and Shamy have more give or take. Shamy more take lol. But point is it is just typical tyrant Sheldon. Insufferable Sheldon. He is basically a big baby who needs to get his own way. Leonard lets him. It is only when it is made clear to Sheldon his behaviour is not okay, he seems to adapt. But he tends to degress at times too. 

You are probably right, but it is really starting getting old. Especially not too long ago we had (again) a very jealous Sheldon, who basically needed everyone to guid his feelings and behavior. And where it earlier on was funny, it´s imo totally out of place in season 10. Plus, it´´s too central; too Sheldon centric. 

[jenafan]

9 minutes ago, 3ku11 said:

That is why it was funny. Shamy's indifference to Penny's displeasure, is what it funny. But that is just me. Same time happened in Season 5 or when ever we last saw it. Amy was clueless to Penny's displeasure. So basically continuity their. 

I found it funny that Theodore thought Amy in the painting was Penny's mother.  Amy is so vintage, after all.

[RoRo]

I thought it was ok. Not outstanding but not bad either. It does lead us to believe Shamy are going to be permanent in 4b with the redecorating talk, and loved how Amy really wanted Penny to have that painting. I'm easily entertained.

 

[john2p]

I am very biased when it comes to Sheldon and Leonard, it´s because I like to support the underdog in general; I am more into Leonard than Sheldon. But in the earlier days/seasons until season 3-4 I totally get why Jim/Sheldon got all the attention and awards. I just watched again the episode where Penny shot with the paintball on Sheldon´s spot. And that was some awesome acting of Jim (in fact of three of them, Jim, Kaley and Johnny). But Sheldon was really catching the eye. Nowadays it´s Johnny who is taking charge. Where Jim is very close and maybe is, to overacting. It´s not only Johnny dances half naked (sex dungeon and flag). But it seems he is even getting better in delivering his lines on time in combination with the gestures and facial expressions. In some way he reminds me of Michael J. Fox, one of my all time favorite comedic actors. Which is funny because of Christopher Lloyd being in this episode. OHH, maybe MJ should get a guest role appreance  

Edited December 2, 2016 by john2p

[djsurrey]

So even Christopher Lloyd could not save this episode. I gave it an Okay  It is better than the sweater episode. Still it was fun to see Christopher Lloyd. I have my fill of Sheldon-Leonard fight episodes.

[No Regrets]

Casting Christopher Lloyd was kinda pointless, IMO. They really didn't give him any funny lines at all. And I love CL, so that's disappointing.

Super tired of the "Sheldon gets to be mean to Leonard cause he secretly loves his buddy so much" angle. Sheldon belittling Leonard's achievements was never funny and it never will be. He can dish out plenty but as soon as someone fires back he acts like a big whiney baby. It's gotten so, so old. Grow the hell up.

Leonard & Penny were a great team in this episode. 

And I thought Mayim was really funny. I wish we'd see Amy outside of her relationship with Sheldon more, but I understand why that's not possible due to the setup of the show. It's a shame, though, because IMO Amy's character has a lot more comedy to offer. Then again that goes for Leonard & Penny as well. The core problem really is that everything apparently needs to be tied to Sheldon. Well, that's my problem with the show at least.

The whole Howardette/Stuart/Raj plot seemed like something I've seen a dozen times on other shows, only they managed to make it not funny.

[john2p]

14 minutes ago, No Regrets said:

Casting Christopher Lloyd was kinda pointless, IMO. They really didn't give him any funny lines at all. And I love CL, so that's disappointing.

Super tired of the "Sheldon gets to be mean to Leonard cause he secretly loves his buddy so much" angle. Sheldon belittling Leonard's achievements was never funny and it never will be. He can dish out plenty but as soon as someone fires back he acts like a big whiney baby. It's gotten so, so old. Grow the hell up.

Leonard & Penny were a great team in this episode. 

And I thought Mayim was really funny. I wish we'd see Amy outside of her relationship with Sheldon more, but I understand why that's not possible due to the setup of the show. It's a shame, though, because IMO Amy's character has a lot more comedy to offer. Then again that goes for Leonard & Penny as well. The core problem really is that everything apparently needs to be tied to Sheldon. Well, that's my problem with the show at least.

The whole Howardette/Stuart/Raj plot seemed like something I've seen a dozen times on other shows, only they managed to make it not funny.

I can only agree with all your comments. 

[luminous]

I honestly liked the episode. Maybe I belong to that kind of people who are easily entertained.

I loved Team Leonard & Penny.

As for Sheldon's behaviour in this episode, Penny found the right words.

Edited December 2, 2016 by luminous

[Chrismo]

10 minutes ago, luminous said:

I honestly liked the episode. Maybe I belong to that kind of people who are easily entertained.

I loved Team Leonard & Penny.

This is an episode I think that people who didn't like may like when it's repeated in the future. I think some of us who watch thinking this is season 10 see it as repeative comparing it to earlier season episodes espicially with the Shelnard fighting. Season 9 has been repeated lately and while it wasn't the best season IMO I have actually enjoyed some of the episodes more since seeing them the first time.

[3ku11]

15 minutes ago, Chrismo said:

This is an episode I think that people who didn't like may like when it's repeated in the future. I think some of us who watch thinking this is season 10 see it as repeative comparing it to earlier season episodes espicially with the Shelnard fighting. Season 9 has been repeated lately and while it wasn't the best season IMO I have actually enjoyed some of the episodes more since seeing them the first time.

I kinda agree, in the way of repeating cannon. Not as bad as the awful repeated cannon of S8. But it feels Season 6ish to me. Sheldon still being a jerk, an ass, All of the above lol. Degressed. Progressed next episode. Still a dick. I mean it is Season Ten maybe we should expect more, maybe we shoulden't. I guess disposable comes to mind. We have seen Tyranical Sheldon, we have seen Shelnard Fighting. Maybe the show could try be a bit more creative. But hey if its not broke, don't fix it. And I am easily entertained as well, to a certain degree..

1 hour ago, No Regrets said:

Casting Christopher Lloyd was kinda pointless, IMO. They really didn't give him any funny lines at all. And I love CL, so that's disappointing.

Super tired of the "Sheldon gets to be mean to Leonard cause he secretly loves his buddy so much" angle. Sheldon belittling Leonard's achievements was never funny and it never will be. He can dish out plenty but as soon as someone fires back he acts like a big whiney baby. It's gotten so, so old. Grow the hell up.

Leonard & Penny were a great team in this episode. 

And I thought Mayim was really funny. I wish we'd see Amy outside of her relationship with Sheldon more, but I understand why that's not possible due to the setup of the show. It's a shame, though, because IMO Amy's character has a lot more comedy to offer. Then again that goes for Leonard & Penny as well. The core problem really is that everything apparently needs to be tied to Sheldon. Well, that's my problem with the show at least.

The whole Howardette/Stuart/Raj plot seemed like something I've seen a dozen times on other shows, only they managed to make it not funny.

I laughed lol.. Stuart is hilarous

[mirs1]

I rated it "good"; I had great expectations on CL being in the show and, TBH, they were not fulfilled. He had unfunny lines and I didn't like that much him being kind of a DR. Phil and helping Shelnard to sort their feelings out. Also B/H/R/S plot was underwhelming. I think the jokes about poor, depressed, broken Stuart are getting old and him and Raj fighting for Howardette's attentions was a bit creepy. Anyway, I liked very much the first part the episode. It was full of good memories about the show, the painting, the GoT sword, the 3-d chess,  the apartment flag have been part of so many good moments in the past seasons and I liked the idea of a "nostalgia" episode to make Shelnard break up official. Sheldon and Leonard fighting and planning retaliation towards each other was also very "old" school and I liked that. I guess this episode was supposed to be a sort of bridge between two different phases of the show and it had this vibe. For me Shelnard is the best broommance ever, so always happy when I see them together, even if they fight. As I said, anyway, I would have preferred that they settled their differences without somebody suggesting them "this anger comes from love..." Amy and Sheldon offering the painting back to Penny and her face on receiving it was priceless, the best part of the episode for me. I also like Shamy are going to redecorate 4B, that place is too "Penny" right now.

Edited December 2, 2016 by mirs1

[3ku11]

Hmmm maybe we should revise why we have great expectations for this show in the first place. Maybe we should lower them lol.. Because I have to agree, CL apperence was underwhelming. I was also expecting a big ovation, but he got nothing. Maybe they edited that out. I don't know. While I personally found some of his line funny. "Is that your Mum?" hahah. But I Get, he was just some guy who moved into Lenny's Apt Room. But who is he? What is his background? I get he is a cameo character. But I Think it just seemed a wasted cameo for such a legend of Entertainment in the end. I am sure CL had fun, and it was great seeing him on the show. But it did feel underwhelming. 

Edited December 2, 2016 by 3ku11

[luminous]

26 minutes ago, mirs1 said:

Amy and Sheldon offering the painting back to Penny and her face on receiving it was priceless

Priceless, indeed.

[john2p]

OK I watched it a second time. Maybe I was to harsh with my criticism the first time. I still am not that thrilled about this episode. Especially the Shelnard and Raj-Stuart thing. and Christopher´s character feels out of place. But I liked the Lenny and the Shamy. The little glimpse of Howardette was also cute imo. They all seem in a pretty good place. I rated it as an ok episode. 

Edited December 2, 2016 by john2p